20 Years Later, This Widely Hated Blockbuster Is Still One of Hollywood’s Most Underrated Thrillers
As M. Night Shyamalan's latest film, "Trap," starring Josh Hartnett, prepares to hit theaters without any advance press screenings, it's worth revisiting one of the director's most controversial and misunderstood films: "The Village." Released 20 years ago, this blockbuster was met with widespread disdain but has since emerged as a poignant and underrated gem in Shyamalan's oeuvre.
The Rise and Fall of M. Night Shyamalan
Shyamalan's career has been a rollercoaster of critical acclaim and backlash, often tied to his penchant for plot twists. Starting with the groundbreaking "The Sixth Sense" in 1999, Shyamalan became known for his ability to shock audiences with unexpected revelations. However, this reputation eventually turned into a punchline, with critics and audiences alike growing weary of his reliance on twists.
The Village: A Turning Point
"The Village," released in 2004, marked a significant turning point in Shyamalan's career. The film, set in a secluded rural community living in fear of mythic creatures in the woods, was met with harsh criticism and audience disappointment. The movie's two major twists—revealing that there were no monsters and that the village was actually set in modern times—were seen as cheap tricks, leading many to label Shyamalan as a master of cinematic deception.
Reevaluating The Village
However, upon closer inspection and with the benefit of hindsight, "The Village" reveals itself to be a deeply layered and emotionally resonant film. The movie explores themes of societal control, the dangers of nostalgia, and the impact of fear on community dynamics. Shyamalan's use of primary colors and Bryce Dallas Howard's compelling performance as Ivy add to the film's visual and emotional depth.
A Masterpiece of Subtlety
"The Village" is less a traditional thriller and more a Twilight Zone-esque melodrama, akin to an Edith Wharton novel. The film's dialogue, while initially perceived as stilted, serves a purpose, reflecting the characters' intentional or accidental imitation of old-timey vernacular. This aspect underscores the sad absurdity of the community's self-imposed limitations and the romanticized notion of an earlier era.
The Village's Timeless Themes
In today's context, "The Village" feels even more relevant, particularly in the wake of political movements advocating a return to a "purer" past. The film's exploration of the burdens and anxieties of parenthood, questioning whether protecting children can sometimes close them off from richer experiences, adds another layer of depth to its narrative.
The Village's Legacy
Despite its initial reception, "The Village" has endured as a testament to Shyamalan's ability to craft complex, thought-provoking stories. The film's twists, while controversial, fundamentally change the nature of what audiences think they're watching, challenging them to reconsider their perceptions and interpretations.
As Shyamalan continues to navigate the highs and lows of his career, "The Village" stands as a reminder of his unique talent for blending suspense, emotion, and social commentary. In the end, it is one of Hollywood's most underrated thrillers, a film that deserves a second look and a deeper appreciation.
"The Village" is available to rent or purchase from major digital services. For more of A.A. Dowd's writing, please visit his Authory page.